Last weekend I had a wedding to go to, which means that after totally screwing up the dress code—cocktail and formal are not the same thing I had to up my beauty game for the evening (since it’s basically non-existent), so I got crazy and decided to include a little liquid eyeliner in my look.

I have to say, it looked pretty cool, but at the end of the night when I looked in the mirror it looked like you could literally peel it off my eyes. It went from looking glossy and pretty to looking like a piece of tape on my eyelids.

So in an effort to not look like a crazy person the next time I try to nice-ify my face, what’s the deal? Do you use liquid eyeliner and if so what brands have you found work well? Or do you stick with a regular kohl pencil? Help!!